Search Museum Next

Museums Don’t Need More Visitors. They Need More Contributors.

Above: Anna Stolyarova with the mural Tolerance

On a wall in Amsterdam’s Nieuw-West district, a mural called Tolerance is fading away. Nobody is rushing to restore it. And yet it is still part of a museum collection.

That collection belongs to Street Art Museum Amsterdam (SAMA), a museum without a building. Its hallways are the neighbourhood’s streets. Its artworks are the walls. Its visitors are the people who live there, who are also its contributors and, as founder Anna Stolyarova likes to point out, its sharpest critics.

A museum whose collection is quite literally vanishing has had to face questions most institutions can put off. Who creates cultural value? Who decides what is worth passing on? And what is a museum for when the knowledge it needs already exists outside its walls? SAMA’s approach to citizen science in museums offers a challenge to the whole sector: let residents help shape what the museum knows, preserves and values.

Citizen science when you can’t save the object

Around 2017, SAMA’s collection began to disappear. Buildings were renovated or torn down, and the neighbourhood’s public space entered a new phase of transition. At first it looked like a conservation problem: how do you preserve something that is vanishing? The honest answer was that sometimes you don’t.

That raised harder questions. If you can’t keep the object, what exactly are you recording for future generations? And who decides what makes it into history?

Those questions, says Stolyarova, changed SAMA far more than any technology ever did. Once you take them seriously, the usual roles blur. Residents stop being audiences to “engage”. Artists are no longer the only makers, researchers no longer the only interpreters, and the museum is no longer the only place where knowledge sits.

At SAMA, that knowledge is spread across the neighbourhood. It sits with the artist who made a work, and the researcher who used it to start a conversation with the community. It sits with the transport company that used a mural to promote a new cycle route, and the housing corporation that knows when a building will come down. Above all, it sits with the resident who hated the piece from day one.

Citizen science gave SAMA a way to take all of that seriously. Residents are no longer the subjects of research. They can be researchers too.

The participation trap in museums

Museums have become far better at participation over the past decade. Workshops, storytelling evenings and co-created exhibitions are now standard fare. But there is a trap hidden in the word.

The museum asks the questions. The museum designs the methods. The museum gathers the data. And at the end, the museum publishes its opinion. “Participation took place,” says Stolyarova, “yet authority has never left the building.”

SAMA’s Streetwise project set out to move that authority around. Residents and young people observed their own neighbourhood, identified what mattered, asked who and what was missing, and helped interpret the findings.

The difference is in the invitation. Participation says: “Come and contribute to our museum.” Citizen-led knowledge asks: “What do you already know that changes how our museum understands this place?”

Artists have to let go too

Museums aren’t the only ones who need to loosen their grip. Through STAR 2.0, a European project that developed and tested a street art toolkit for youth workers in several countries, SAMA found that artists face the same tension. The goal was never just to paint murals. Street art was the method; the real work was peer-to-peer learning about how young people, artists and communities shape shared space.

Which raises an awkward question: what happens when the artist arrives with one idea and the community has another?

Cika Schultz, an artist and youth worker, recently led a co-creation project at SAMA in which neighbourhood children helped paint a mural. She based the design on a child’s drawing of a big tree, and the children coloured in every section. She shows them how to use spray paint, then steps back and lets them make mistakes. “In a co-creation project,” she says, “sometimes I have to let go of my own artistic voice.”

She still picks her battles. The children have real freedom, but some things, like very fluorescent reds, stay off the table.

That is where the line between token and genuine participation falls. If a young person can only choose between three colours the artist has already picked, you could call it participation. But if something they know, remember or challenge actually changes the work, their knowledge has consequences. The artist hasn’t disappeared, and neither has authorship. Authority, though, has become shared.

One of SAMA’s youth workers describes street art as not a destination but a way of getting there. The method is not complicated: “Yes, and…” You bring an idea, I bring another, and neither has to be cancelled to make room for the other. No museum can ever declare itself “fully participatory”. It is a way of working: asking, returning, being corrected and trying again.

Disagreement is data

Street art is, in Stolyarova’s words, “a wonderful troublemaker” when it comes to heritage value. A technically brilliant work can mean nothing to the people who live beside it. A modest one can carry a huge weight of local memory. Heritage professionals can love what residents dislike, and residents can treasure what institutions barely notice.

So who gets the final vote? The artist, the museum, the residents, the municipality, the housing corporation, the heritage expert? SAMA’s answer is increasingly: none of the above.

This is not just a small museum’s problem. In the recent publication The Museum of the Future: Now What?, curators, directors and architects from some of the world’s biggest institutions wrestle with what the museum should become. SAMA sits at the opposite end of the food chain, yet lands on the same question: who gets to decide?

Through work linked to the Faro Convention, which puts people and communities at the heart of how heritage is recognised and passed on, SAMA has been testing ways to make different perspectives visible. Give several groups the same artwork and the same background information, and ask them to value it. They disagree. That is not a failure of method. It is information. SAMA is now taking this approach to the National Monument Congress with the Cultural Heritage Agency.

Street art also forces a rethink of preservation itself. Walls are demolished, paste-ups weather, stickers are peeled off and whole neighbourhoods are rebuilt, yet meaning can survive. None of this is an argument against conservation. It is an argument for a sharper question: what exactly are we trying to pass on, in what form, and to whom? Ask that, and the museum’s job shifts from guarding objects to helping people negotiate what should travel into the future.

Beware the digital mausoleum

Sooner or later, someone says “technology”. SAMA is building a digital street art depot, and its first prototype is live: 80% open source and ready for other institutions to clone. The team uses 360-degree documentation, photogrammetry, AI reconstruction and Gaussian splatting — “wonderful toys for people who love to make their computers suffer,” says Stolyarova, whose own background is digital.

The danger comes when we mistake a digital copy for preserved meaning. A 3D model can capture the colour of a wall in crisp detail, but not why the wall mattered. AI can fill in missing visual information, and a database can organise 10,000 files. Neither can decide whose memory carries weight, or which relationships must stay connected for meaning to survive.

SAMA has a phrase for this: community intelligence is not artificial intelligence. The digital layer only becomes meaningful when it reconnects an object to its social life: the artist, the place, the residents, the memories, the decisions, the disagreements, even a newspaper clipping. Without that, museums risk building extremely sophisticated digital mausoleums — perfect records of things whose social lives nobody thought to capture.

Three ways to share museum knowledge and authority

SAMA is unusual. It works in public space, its collection is unstable and its boundaries are porous. But its principles travel. You don’t need a street art collection, a new department, a five-year digital strategy or expensive software to start.

  1. Change one question. Instead of “How do we get this community to engage with our collection?”, ask “What does this community know that our collection does not?” A tiny change, and a completely different relationship.
  2. Return interpretation. When people share stories, observations or memories, don’t feed them into the institutional machine and disappear. Take your interpretation back to them. Is this what you meant? Who is missing? What did we get wrong? It isn’t glamorous. It is accountability.
  3. Document disagreement. Museums are excellent at authoritative labels. Sometimes the most honest label would read: “We asked. People did not agree.” Keep the competing meanings. A museum doesn’t lose authority by showing disagreement; it becomes more precise about where that authority comes from.

From visitors to contributors

Change who produces knowledge, and sooner or later you have to change what you count as success.

Most museums ask how many people came and whether they enjoyed the exhibition. Geertje, who works alongside SAMA, suggests a better question: who came, and whose knowledge was actually included when the exhibition was made? That goes to the heart of whose knowledge counts.

Which brings us to a deliberately provocative claim: museums do not need more visitors. Of course visitors matter. “Please don’t go home and tell your director that a lady in Amsterdam told you to close your ticket desk,” says Stolyarova. The real question is what happens if visitor numbers stop being our dominant measure of public value, and we start recording contributors alongside them.

A contributor, in SAMA’s definition, is not someone who was invited, or who turned up, or even someone who handed over a story, a photograph or an opinion. A contributor is somebody whose knowledge had consequences.

At SAMA, those consequences are everywhere. An artist’s mural changes because young people know something she doesn’t. Interpretation changes because residents say the museum got it wrong. Ideas of heritage change because people value the same artwork differently. The digital archive changes because preserving the image isn’t enough. And the definition of success changes because someone asked whether the museum itself was willing to change.

SAMA thought its problem was that it couldn’t preserve everything. The more interesting problem turned out to be deciding what preservation is for, and who gets to decide. Perhaps a museum’s job is sometimes less about collecting and more about creating the conditions for different kinds of knowledge to meet, disagree, correct one another and stay connected.

The question, then, isn’t how to make museums more interactive to attract more visitors. It’s who gets to produce knowledge in the first place, and what happens when that knowledge has consequences.


This article is based upon a presentation by Anna Stolyarova, founder of Street Art Museum Amsterdam, at the Creative Museums Summit in October 2026.

About the author – Manuel Charr

Manuel Charr is a journalist working in the arts and cultural sectors. With a background in marketing, Manuel is drawn to arts organizations which are prepared to try inventive ways to reach new audiences.

Related Content

Why We Need Museums Now More Than Ever — The Importance of Museums

In today’s uncertain times, museums can act as an anchor in the storm. To those who aren’t as passionate about the power of museums as...

How Can Museums Attract More Visitors?

Attracting more museum visitors starts with understanding who is missing and why. A campaign can give people a reason to consider a visit, but practical...

Six Museum Audio Tour Ideas and What They Require

Museum audio can do several different jobs: create atmosphere, help visitors choose what to see, describe an artwork or lead a branching story. The best...

Subscribe to the latest museum thinking

Fresh ideas from museums around the globe in your inbox each week