Search Museum Next

Dave Patten on Adaptable Museum Interfaces During COVID-19

Dave Patten from Science Museum speaking at a MuseumNext Conference

At a February 2021 virtual roundtable, Dave Patten took Jim Richardson and the MuseumNext community through London’s Science Museum’s experiences during 2020. The discussion covered adaptable interfaces, mobile audio and pandemic-era cleaning and touch-avoidance ideas; it records that period’s discussion rather than current health advice.

At the time of the roundtable, Dave Patten managed a team within London’s Science Museum’s digital directorate that developed and delivered all of the in-museum digital experiences – incorporating film, computer games and digital interpretation. Over the years, the Science Museum has cultivated a reputation for its incredible levels of interactivity and visitor engagement.

But during the height of a pandemic, the more tactile and hands-on an exhibition or installation, the greater the challenge to run. In the February 2021 meet-up, Dave kicked things off by talking through his own experiences in 2020. He said,

“When we first went into lockdown we spent quite a bit of time auditing everything in the museum, trying to find out what we’d need to do to reopen the museum to make it Covid safe.”

Like many other institutions around the globe, the Science Museum reopened after the first UK lockdown with a massively upgraded cleaning programme and readily available hand sanitiser. Despite the museum’s best efforts this still meant sacrificing some of the museum’s interactive elements – typically where they were designed to come into contact with the face, with the eyes and the ears.

Among the remedial steps that were taken to avoid any loss of audio-visual quality in the experience, Dave says that the Science Museum quickly adapted audio facilities on to people’s mobile devices – usually facilitated by QR codes. This innovation served to maintain much of the continuity in many of the exhibits that had previously utilised headsets, but Dave admits that it is hard to gauge the success and penetration of some of the innovations due to the fact that, during the reopening period the museum was operating at significantly reduced capacity.

Tech testing

As the MuseumNext community shared their experiences of trying new approaches to Covid challenges, Dave confirmed that one of the key considerations that informed the Science Museum’s approach was always the ability to test. While there may have been a number of avenues open to the digital and exhibitions teams, he stated that they weren’t prepared to introduce any technologies that hadn’t been tested rigorously and proven to work in the right way for visitors.

Nevertheless, Dave suggested that there is undoubtedly a case to be made for hands-free or personal device-based interfaces becoming more prevalent in the future. This is not only because these technologies are engaging but also because the patterns of 2020 might become ingrained in behaviours long after the health risks of Coronavirus have subsided:

“I think the longer the pandemic goes on, the more likely we are to see permanent behavioural shifts. And it may be that people are increasingly reticent to touch even touchscreens because they’ve become so accustomed to not interacting in that.”

With that in mind, Dave’s focus for new installations will be on briefing new software development that is always built with flexibility of interface as a priority. Asked if the Science Museum runs the risk of investigating and implementing technologies that will become redundant after the pandemic passes, Dave says, “That’s why we’re trying to abstract the interface from the content so that it’s easy to change.”

The most transferable design point in this February 2021 discussion is the separation of an exhibit’s content from the interface used to reach it. A museum can keep the same story while testing whether visitors should use a touchscreen, their own phone or another control. Patten’s account also makes clear why testing with visitors matters before choosing a replacement.

The use of mobile phones, in particular, is something, the Science Museum has investigated extensively, having commissioned work previously in 2012 and 2016 and to look at the barriers to broader usage by visitors. In February 2021, Dave explained that the research was being repeated because the team suspected that visitor habits had changed since the earlier studies.

Livdeo’s approach to visitor-owned devices offers a contrasting account of delivering interpretation without loaned hardware.

Handling hygiene issues

Another topic of conversation during the virtual roundtable was the range of techniques being explored to facilitate greater hygiene for visitors. From chemical screen treatments to single-use styluses, all have been floated as ideas in recent months. The group discussed the pros and cons of these tools and techniques from a safety, sustainability and, of course, practicality perspective.

Due to the varying touchscreen technologies at the Science Museum, Dave said, “It would have meant using at least two different types of stylus required for a visitor. Then there’s the sheer number we’d need – and we were concerned about people just taking them and dropping them in the street, and that not being very sustainable”.

Future trends

The community also looked at future trends and what might be around the corner for museums visitors. From using mobile phones for in-museum experiences to gesture-based interfaces and haptic exhibits, it was agreed that much could be learned from this period of experimentation.

Immersive Digital Environment by TeamLab

Above: Immersive Digital Environment by TeamLab

Looking ahead from February 2021, Dave described plans for the Science Museum’s 2022 programme and beyond. He said, “At the moment, I’m looking at large scale projected immersive environments . . . environments where you’re projecting onto the wall and the floor. And you’re putting motion tracking in the space.

“What we’re really interested in from a Science Museum perspective is telling some of those stories that are not easily told using objects. So, for example, how do you help people understand quantum computing?”

In the case of the Science Museum, the process for developing and launching an exhibition is quite elongated – even without the trials and tribulations of a global virus on the loose. The planning stages and research undertaken with technology companies can take many months to piece together – first in terms of scope and budget, then rigorous fundraising to get the exhibition going.

The group also discussed the value of looking outside the sector for future inspiration, input and ideas. Dave says:

“If you always just look to museums you just get what museums have always done. There are people doing a host of interesting things in a whole variety of different fields. We’re really fortunate that we get to see a lot of that. But you can never look too widely for ideas. The challenge is just to stay up to date with where all that stuff is going.”

Dave points to theme parks such Disney and Universal, as examples of organisations that can help to spark ideas in the museum space – particularly in the context of visitor interface.

Of course, ideas can travel in the other direction as well. In the case of the Science Museum, high-end retail brands have sought advice in the past regarding experiences in biometrics, personalisation, and projection techniques.

About the author – Tim Deakin

Tim Deakin is a journalist and editorial consultant working with a broad range of online publications.

Related Content

Nick Hodder on Building an Adaptable Museum Digital Strategy

At MuseumNext Live, Nick Hodder, then Assistant Director of Digital Transformation at Imperial War Museums, delivered a lively and thought-provoking presentation on what digital transformation...

How Auckland Museum Built Membership During the Pandemic

Launching a new initiative is never easy, but doing so during a global pandemic is an entirely different challenge. Christiane Pracht, Membership Manager at Auckland...

Can Museum Shops Go Plastic-Free? Inside Manchester Museum’s Eco Revolution

When Manchester Museum reopened its doors in February 2023 after a £15m transformation, it was more than just a fresh look. The museum embraced a...

Subscribe to the latest museum thinking

Fresh ideas from museums around the globe in your inbox each week