Fresh ideas from museums around the globe in your inbox each week

First published in February 2022, this article examines audience-segmentation research and reopening decisions from 2020–21. Model descriptions and service examples below refer to that period.
Do you know your Commuterland Culturebuffs from your Kaleidoscope Creativity? These are (as the segmentation savvy will know) two of the profiles from the Audience Agency’s ‘Audience Spectrum’ segmentation model. This model helps cultural organisations to better understand audiences in the UK.
Whether this question leaves you nodding sagely or scratching your head, the reopening period offers a useful example of how museums can use audience segmentation to inform decisions.
Segmentation models are used across all industries to refine marketing messages. They range from comprehensive systems such as Experian’s ‘Mosaic’ system (which is built from a vast pool of consumer and demographic data – including information from the Office of National Statistics (ONS), YouGov and Research Now) to arts, culture and heritage specific models. For example, consultancy Morris Hargreaves McIntyre’s ‘Culture Segments’ has been developed from their experiences working with organisations around the world.
These are powerful tools to help museums understand their audiences (and potential audiences) better. Segmentation models group visitors into similar types so that we can effectively tailor our engagement strategies.
When you research your museum’s audiences, segmentation models can offer useful lenses on motivation, behaviour and circumstances. Similarities with your own personas can suggest questions to investigate, but a home-made persona should not simply be assigned a proprietary segment. Formal classification needs the provider’s method, and any model should be checked against what you learn from your museum’s audiences.
Plus, these models have a continual investment in research and development and during the pandemic, this has been more vital than ever.

Morris Hargreaves McIntyre was quick to react and by May 2020 they had conducted initial research and published a three-part think piece on Culture in Lockdown, including an insightful addition to their Culture Segments model – the Covid Audience Mindsets.
The Culture Segments model defines eight audience types, and the psychographic approach describes these audiences in terms of their beliefs, values, and key motivators.
The Covid Audience Mindsets added attitudes to digital engagement and reopening to this research, offering valuable insights into what these segments would need and value during the pandemic – giving organisations the support to swiftly shape strategic plans.
“The recovery may be slow, and we will need to strategise for that,” Andrew McIntyre says in part 1 of his think-piece. “While there may be pent-up demand and certain audience segments may return sooner, other segments may be wary or their spending power weakened, certain types of offer and settings (outdoor?) may, initially, be more attractive, and there may be legal and practical restrictions on what we’re able to deliver.”
He says confidently that audiences, including tourists, will return but that as a result of the pandemic museums have pushed some people further along the digital adoption curve, which will merely enhance, not replace, the analogue.
“Already, there are attempts to model and predict future audience intent. While we’re all eager to get a first glimpse of what might happen, here we really should counsel caution. What people are currently doing is knowable. It’s way more reliable than what people say they might do next week or next month, let alone in some post-lockdown future.
“That’s why the reflex impulse to embark on big audience tracking studies will be far less useful to our organisations than small-scale evaluation and consultation. Right now, deep data is far more valuable than big data.”
By the time this article was published in February 2022, these reopening discussions had reinforced the value of understanding motivations and barriers alongside larger audience datasets.
At the time, the consultancy discussed TagTool for enriching box-office data, a Covid Audience Mindsets Survey and consultation as ways to understand audiences’ readiness to return. These are historical service examples; museums considering a model should check its current method and availability with the provider.
Reports discussed in 2021 gave more detailed insights into audiences, for example in New Zealand during 2020, and for reopening in Washington DC – offering a greater understanding of behaviours and intentions during the period studied.
“What both Culture Segments and Covid Audience Mindsets illustrate is that it is not socio-demographics which drive people’s desire to engage with culture or to return to in-venue engagement, although there are some slight correlations with age for example,” Jo Hargreaves, Director at Morris Hargreaves McIntyre told MuseumNext.
“It’s psychographics – their deeper-seated values which determine what they want from engaging with culture – and in terms of their propensity to return, their levels of emotional resilience and attitudes to risk and we found low or high levels of these exist in relatively equal measures across different age-groups. So if we want to most effectively encourage return we need to understand these deeper drivers”.
The Audience Agency also provided a version of their Audience Spectrum segmentation system which reflects how attitudes and behaviour have been affected by the pandemic.
Audience Spectrum provides detail on ten culturally active segments based on demographic data. It highlights the benefit of having in place an audience segmentation model that, while being based on cultural engagement, is also linked to demographics, geography and the many concrete factors that have made so much difference to people’s lives.
In the report it says that those differences ‘have had particular effects during lockdown, but also relate to things that we know have always made a difference to cultural consumption (things like age, education, health and household composition’.
In the context of COVID-19, this takes into account if a segment is more prevalent in areas that had earlier infection peaks (for example), age and likelihood of shielding, and segments that may have been impacted by ‘bubbling’.
This addition to Audience Spectrum was accompanied by a wide array of audience-analysis services discussed during reopening, and ‘this constantly developing suite of audience analysis tools and evidence-led support is designed to help arts organisations build back better from the COVID-19 pandemic’.
The toolkit included the Cultural Participation Monitor, a longitudinal study from which key findings are published quarterly. The reporting offered a view of changing intentions; for example, the Autumn 21 report included audiences’ expected interest for the 2021 festive period.
During lockdown, the Audience Agency also offered organisations the Digital Audience Survey. This survey enabled organisations to continue to gather information through lockdown, and suggested the emergence of new behaviours – lower engaged audiences who are interested in digital content – offering questions about digital engagement for museums to explore.
A segment becomes useful when it changes a decision. For a new evening event, one group may want time with friends, while another wants a closer encounter with the collection. The same programme can be introduced through those different interests without changing what the museum stands for. Use short conversations and booking behaviour to check the fit, and keep refining the message as you learn who responds and who still faces barriers to attending.
To turn audience insight into a marketing plan, record the programme, the audience motivation or barrier, the message and the desired action. Compare responses by the groups your research can reliably identify. Geographic information may help you reach local visitors, but it should be considered alongside access, confidence and interests.
The pandemic examples show how models can respond to changing circumstances. Keep reviewing the research behind a model and its fit with the decision your museum needs to make.
And it’s important for museums to continually assess their audience understanding, too. Investing in data collection and analysis will help to ensure that they can make the most of the insights available – and vitally to best serve their visitors.
Explore related practice at MuseumNext’s upcoming events.
Rebecca Hardy Wombell is a freelance writer who works with a broad range of creative organisations, including artists, galleries, museums and design-led retailers.
Her writing aims to develop and delight audiences by putting her clients’ beautiful works to well-crafted words.
Fresh ideas from museums around the globe in your inbox each week