Search Museum Next

Moving A Seat at the Table into a Virtual Conversation Space

In 2022, museum teams were considering what they had learned from taking discussion programmes online during pandemic restrictions. A Seat at the Table offered a case of adapting both expert discussion and conversation among participants.

At the MuseumNext Digital Summit 2022, Deidre Cross and Leslie Walker from the Smithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture and Joey Tackett from ForumOne explored where this greater digital acceptance and reliance on screens leaves arts and cultural organisations that are seeking to initiate meaningful conversations with their audiences through in-person events?

Adapting an established discussion programme

A Seat at the Table was already an established in-person programme before the pandemic, with museum records documenting events in 2017. The digital challenge was to adapt its combination of expert discussion and participant conversation when people could no longer gather around a shared meal.

The Covid-19 pandemic disrupted the established in-person series in 2020. The 2022 account described an initial online format using Zoom breakout rooms to support conversations that had taken place around physical tables.

From a learning perspective, there were some problematic aspects of virtual hosting in obtaining the right outcome for this kind of programme, namely Zoom itself.  A Seat at the Table combined an expert panel with conversation among participants. The team described wanting a more fluid experience than its initial online format provided.

Given the wider context of 2020 and the pressure cooker of intense emotions – particularly the Black Lives Matter protests – the programme had an important role as a space to cultivate opinions and discuss them safely and critically.  And so, Seat at The Table needed to change to make the online experience more fluid and reflect that value the museum placed on the outcomes.

Making space for participant conversation

To make the technical aspects of digital events less cumbersome and more focused on encouraging meaningful conversation, the museum team worked with Forum One to establish new delivery platforms that would support a move away from Zoom. The team described using Social Hour for a virtual-table format to support participant conversation. Social Hour was the historical tool in this account; the programme design depended on how the discussion was hosted and facilitated.

The virtual representation was one part of the design. The format, staff preparation, discussion prompts and facilitation also mattered to the conversations the programme aimed to support.

Planning participation in virtual programmes means assigning the hosting and facilitation work as deliberately as the content.

Planning the facilitation as well as the platform

Aside from considering the graphical presentation of a discussion forum when switching to an online format, the team at the Smithsonian also devised a number of other key recommendations for running virtual events:

  1. Consider your topics carefully, they must respond to current events.
  2. Assemble a diverse panel that represents academics and practitioners with real experiences but also activists who can set out how to influence policy change and implement positive output based on the conversations.
  3. Be realistic about the resources available as to get the most out of the opportunity there needs to be a focus on the planning as well as effective hosting and facilitating of discussions.
  4. Make your forum authentic to the values of your institution – maybe a formal dinner is not right but a cocktail hour or potluck style could make panellists more comfortable.
  5. Do you understand the hosting platform and its technical requirements? Plan how discussion cues will appear, how participants will join a conversation and what support they need. Check the exact functions rather than assuming that every virtual-table platform works in the same way.
  6. What does the event mean? Are you seeking answers, opinions or real-world insight? An understanding of outcomes will help to refine the panel and format of the event to great effect

Ethical choices in difficult-history interpretation also matter when designing a conversation around emotionally charged material.

This article is based on the presentation “Facilitating Meaningful Conversations on Social Justice in a Virtual Space” by Deirdre Cross, Leslie Walker and Joey Tackett at the Museum Digital Summit 2022, organised by MuseumNext.

 

–

MuseumNext offer online learning for museum professionals striving for engaging, relevant and flexible professional growth content. Learn more about our virtual museum conferences here.

Related Content

Rethinking Content Strategy at The National Archives: Moving Beyond the Blog

In an age where information is consumed in bite-sized chunks and attention spans are shrinking, how do you ensure that a thousand years of history...

When the Museum Becomes a Space for Emotions: Inside the Biosphère’s Emolab

Montréal’s Biosphère has created an exhibition dedicated entirely to climate emotions — and the story of how it came to exist is almost as compelling...

Museums and Climate: Why Cultural Institutions Belong in the Conversation

From exhibitions that turn industrial heritage into hope to galleries built for climate grief, museums are finding their voice on the defining issue of our...

Subscribe to the latest museum thinking

Fresh ideas from museums around the globe in your inbox each week